John Singer Sargent is among the most talented painter of portraits in the history of art. His talent was well known and well respected, so much so that in the prime of his career, many rich patrons paid small fortunes for the privilege to have their portraits be painted by him. Despite his immense popularity, he had many critics that disagreed with his painting style and the manner of his life as a whole. The unusual station into which Sargent was born, accompanied by the reality that he lived in Europe as his artistic genius was developing, had great influence on him and his artistic style. While he is classified as an American realist, his upbringing caused him to develop a unique style that challenged the norms of the American realism movement. A prime example of this is Sargent’s Mrs. Edward Goetz, which encapsulates the unique, and some-what contrary, nature of his artistic style, and also illustrates indirectly the history of John Singer Sargent as a man.
Sargent’s upbringing is a key that one needs to look at when considering why Sargent was different than the other American artists of his time. Though Sargent was an American, he wasn’t actually born in America, but rather in Florence, Italy. He was born to expatriate parents, who left America and went to Europe after his older sister died (prior to his birth) at age two and his mother to experience significant psychological problems.1 The voyage was not meant to be permanent. His father, who desired to return home and resume his practice as a physician, eventually was forced to retire. Sargent scholar, Stanley Olson, describes the situation of Sargent’s father:
“For two and a half years he had been ready to go home; for two and ahalf years he had lived in that hope and, paradoxically, for two and a half years he had moved with certainty away from that very potentiality. [He] relinquished his ambition, his career, the society of his parents, brothers and sisters, and... retired.”2 Sargent was born into a family that had experienced the tragedy of the death of a child, as well as the later death of two younger siblings of Sargent; a family that lived as nomadic life away from their country of citizenship; and a family whose patriarch had given up everything that he had worked his entire life for. When studying Sargent, this context must be considered as a key role in the development of the man who became the artist.
Sargent inherited a life of an expatriate at birth, and as a result of this, coupled with the fact that his family’s living situation was transitory in nature, he was educated in the cultures of various countries languages and cultures of Europe. Indeed his European upbringing afforded him the opportunity to study at schools, and with people that he wouldn’t have otherwise. One example of this is also quite possibly the single most influential moment in the artistic training of John Singer Sargent, it is when when he began to study with Carolus-Duran, an immensely popular French portrait painter and teacher.3 Carolus-Duran’s style of art was one that allowed the artist to paint directly on the canvas, which allowed freedom with colors and spontaneity with brush strokes. It was Carolus-Duran that eventually convinced Sargent to pursue a career painting portraits, thereby changing Sargent’s focus and allowing for one of the greatest portrait artists ever to emerge. In fact Sargent began his career by painting a portrait of Carolus-Duran which was critically received very positively, and is widely thought to indicate the path that Sargent would take as an artist. He displayed the painting in a prominent French art exhibition as a homage to his teacher and as an display of his portrait abilities.4 The influence that Carolus- Duran had on Sargent’s art cannot be overstated. The artist that emerged from the young, nomadic, expatriate was directly a result of the tutelage of Carolus-Duran.
The culmination of Sargent’s life and training is manifested through his work, in particular his piece entitled Mrs. Edward Goetz. In this painting Sargent painted an old woman shortly before she died. The style with which he painted this painting was a direct result of the upbringing that he received in Europe as a young expatriate. This style can be seen in the brushstrokes that compose the painting which are clearly influenced by training with Carolus- Duran. The brushstrokes have a spontaneous and almost hurried feel to them, yet with great precision Sargent captures incredible details. One particular detail that he captures is the textures of the fabrics shown in the painting. There are two fabrics in particular that illustrate his mastery with a brush: the shawl and the dress. He perfectly represented both fabrics, to the extent that they look like actual cloth on the canvas, however the fabrics are very different. The shawl is light weight and sheer and the dress is heavy and dark, yet both unique fabric types are represented on the same fabric with incredible accuracy. Sargent’s young life as an expatriate allowed him to the opportunity to study with Carolus-Duran, and without that experience Sargent may have become a very different artist.
Sargent uses color to offer a deep contrast in this portrait to greater enhance the beauty that was his subject. At the bottom of the canvas the colors are very dark, and as the picture approaches the top of the canvas they get lighter. The single greatest point of light, however, is Mrs. Edward Goetz’s face. He painted her face in a flattering and beautiful manner. Many critics believe that Sargent painted his subjects in the best light possible so that he could please his customers and be more profitable. There is an alternative explanation when evaluating Sargent’s work; one must view it in the context of Sargent’s life. He certainly did portray his subjects in a
positive and flattering light, but this could possibly be because his childhood had dark and tragic events in it, and he chose to portray the more optimistic side of reality through a persons beauty, instead of their faults. In the painting Mrs. Edward Goetz, a window is opened into Sargent’s life and training that allows us to see more accurately the man and artist he was.
Mrs. Edward Goetz’s is a unique painting by one who was considered an American Realist; the uniqueness it possesses caused him and his style to be criticized. The norms of the American Realism movement, especially with the Ashcan School, was to accurately portray America in an accurate and objective light. Most American Realists used dark, and some-what pessimistic tones, and painted woebegone subjects to illustrate their perception of America. In contrast to this Sargent focused on the lighter tones, and beautiful aspects of his subjects. He was criticized for being an American, who lived in Europe, that chose to paint flattering portraits, rather than socially conscious portrayals of America. Sargent chose to be an optimistic realist in his work, rather than go with the norms of the movement which focused on the dreary.I was particularly impressed with Sargent’s optimistic realism approach when I saw Mrs. Edward Goetz in person. Sargent managed to make a painting look so realistic, and have such depth that I expected Mrs. Goetz to stand up and get out of the painting. Even more impressive to me was how Sargent seemed to capture the essence of her humanity and personality with his paintbrush. Though her eyes were just paint on a canvas, they had light and depth to them the illustrated the uniqueness of her as an individual. The mastery of his technique, coupled with his optimistic approach make his painting fascinating and fun to observe.
Sargent’s upbringing, formal training and his life as an expatriate molded him into the artist that became so impressive and respected. Mrs. Edward Goetz is just one example of his work that helps us understand the context of his art in a very intimate way.
Works Cited
1 Olson, Stanley. John Singer Sargent: His Portrait. 1st ed. New York: St. Martin's Griffin, 2001. p. 1.
2 Olson, Stanley. John Singer Sargent: His Portrait. 1st ed. New York: St. Martin's Griffin, 2001. p. 3.
3 Fairbrother, Trevor. John Singer Sargent. New York: Harry N Abrams, 1994. p. 13.
4 Prettejohn, Elizabeth. Interpreting Sargent. 1st ed. New York: Stewart, Tabori & Chang, 1998. p. 9.